Peer Review

Peer Review Policy

Journal of Library and Information Management, Technology, Education (JOLIMATE)

JOLIMATE uses a rigorous double-blind peer review process. Authors and reviewers remain anonymous to each other. Peer review is independent of author fees; no payment is required to enter or complete peer review.

  1. Initial editorial screening. The Editor-in-Chief (or designate) assesses scope fit, originality, ethical compliance, and basic quality. Manuscripts outside scope or below minimum standards may be desk-rejected without external review.
  2. Similarity check. Submissions are checked with similarity-detection software. Similarity above 15% (excluding references, quotations, and standard methodological phrasing where appropriately cited) typically leads to return or rejection. See the Plagiarism Policy.
  3. Reviewer selection. At least two independent experts are invited based on subject expertise. Reviewers must declare conflicts of interest and decline if they cannot provide an impartial review.
  4. Double-blind review. Reviewers evaluate originality, methodology, relevance, clarity, and contribution, and recommend accept, minor revision, major revision/resubmit, or reject.
  5. Editorial decision. The Editor-in-Chief issues the decision based on the reports. Authors receive anonymised reviewer comments.
  6. Revisions. Authors revise within the stated deadline. Revised manuscripts may be re-reviewed.
  7. Appeals. Authors may appeal a rejection once by writing to the Editor-in-Chief with a reasoned response.
  8. Confidentiality. Manuscripts and reviews are confidential and shared only with those involved in the editorial process.

Detailed expectations for reviewers are published in the Reviewer Guidelines.