Peer Review
Peer Review Policy
Journal of Library and Information Management, Technology, Education (JOLIMATE)
JOLIMATE uses a rigorous double-blind peer review process. Authors and reviewers remain anonymous to each other. Peer review is independent of author fees; no payment is required to enter or complete peer review.
- Initial editorial screening. The Editor-in-Chief (or designate) assesses scope fit, originality, ethical compliance, and basic quality. Manuscripts outside scope or below minimum standards may be desk-rejected without external review.
- Similarity check. Submissions are checked with similarity-detection software. Similarity above 15% (excluding references, quotations, and standard methodological phrasing where appropriately cited) typically leads to return or rejection. See the Plagiarism Policy.
- Reviewer selection. At least two independent experts are invited based on subject expertise. Reviewers must declare conflicts of interest and decline if they cannot provide an impartial review.
- Double-blind review. Reviewers evaluate originality, methodology, relevance, clarity, and contribution, and recommend accept, minor revision, major revision/resubmit, or reject.
- Editorial decision. The Editor-in-Chief issues the decision based on the reports. Authors receive anonymised reviewer comments.
- Revisions. Authors revise within the stated deadline. Revised manuscripts may be re-reviewed.
- Appeals. Authors may appeal a rejection once by writing to the Editor-in-Chief with a reasoned response.
- Confidentiality. Manuscripts and reviews are confidential and shared only with those involved in the editorial process.
Detailed expectations for reviewers are published in the Reviewer Guidelines.